Magnet Central: Weekly Magnet & Campus Fodder
Issue of the Week: Breaking News; A Classic Magnet Administration Over-reaction
I'm assuming that most students are now familiar with what I term to be the "Pork-sandwich throwing of 2006". The gist of it is that some student threw a pork sandwich in the downstairs "A" stairwell, near the main office, at the end of sixth period yesterday, November 15.
Now while this doesn't seem to be such a big deal, a classic overreaction made it a big deal. The punishment for the act was that all the students of Magnet would have to go to their assigned lunch and would have to stay in one room during their co-curricular period. Food would be strictly prohibited in the Senior lounge, and students would not be allowed to utilize the outdoors for eating or sports or whatever. This method is the classic method for attempting to obtain an interrogation from someone who is unwilling to give up the information they know about the incident. Punishing everyone makes the populace angry at whoever did the action and demand a confession from someone, anyone.
While this may be a good method, it was not only an overreaction but was also discriminatory against the Senior class. One stipulation of the rules was that the Seniors could no longer eat in the Senior lounge. Most days prior students would be found in the Senior lounge during fifth period, eating and hanging out. This rule ended all that, and the ironic thing was that from the start it was well known that it was not a Senior who did the act. Early in the day today I even bet money that it wasn't a senior. From what leaks have occurred into the investigation, a confessor has been produced, and ironically enough the sandwich was thrown at a Senior. It's interesting that a Senior was victimized by this incident and was in effect punished twice for something that was not his/her fault.
It's my opinion that the restriction on food in the senior lounge should never have been placed since it's one rule that only affects one of the classes, whereas all the other restrictions are placed upon all the grades. Of course I feel the reaction was over the top, but I don't disagree with it based on the principle that it did have good intentions and did indeed produce a confession.
Kevin


